Former prime ministers and ministers: they are entitled to their report

On November 12, 2026, the Superior Court of Accounts and Administrative Litigation (CSCCA) reminded, in a general opinion, that it is not authorized to grant clearance to former prime ministers and ministers.

Former prime ministers and ministers: they are entitled to their report

Cour Superieure des Comptes (vue architecturale du siège)

On November 12, 2026, the Superior Court of Accounts and Administrative Litigation (CSCCA) reminded, in a general opinion, that it is not authorized to grant clearance to former prime ministers and ministers. In principle, the Court is right. The clearance of an authorizing officer does not fall within its jurisdiction. But that is not the issue at hand. Those who approached it were expecting something else: a report on their management and a document attesting that the Court is not competent to judge their accounts. I believe they are entitled to this. A general opinion does not suffice.<\/p>

What the Court cannot do<\/p>

The decree of November 23, 2005, regarding the organization and functioning of the CSCCA is the starting point. Its article 2 assigns the Court the mission to judge "the accounts of authorizing officers and accountants of public funds." Article 3 clarifies its scope: the Court judges the accounts of public accountants and persons it has declared to be de facto accountants, and it does not have jurisdiction over authorizing officers, except for those it has declared de facto accountants or who would be, like any other person, responsible for irregularities that could constitute faults in management.<\/p>

A prime minister or a minister is an authorizing officer. Therefore, the Court does not have to judge their accounts, nor grant them clearance in the legal sense of the term. The clearance or discharge order, defined in article 18, releases a financial accountant from responsibility and necessarily leads to the removal of mortgage records on their property. It concerns the de jure or de facto accountant.<\/p>

Rendering accounts is not being discharged<\/p>

Rendering accounts and clearance are two distinct things. Article 16 stipulates that rendering accounts is an annual public formality that applies to all concerned, both de jure and de facto accountants.<\/p>

The discharge, on the other hand, is a decision. It does not automatically derive from having rendered accounts. For an accountant, the decision takes the form of a ruling from the Court. For a minister, the discharge is subject to parliamentary consideration. Article 233 of the Constitution provides for a parliamentary commission tasked with reporting on the management of ministers to enable both Assemblies to grant them discharge.<\/p>

Parliamentary discharge does not mean, however, that every expenditure has been regular. This verification falls within the control mandate of the Court. Its report may establish the regularity of expenditures, point out irregularities, or indicate management faults. This is a technical task, distinct from parliamentary consideration, but it must provide parliamentarians with elements to make a decision.<\/p>

What the Court must do<\/p>

The Court's opinion leaves this question unanswered. If the Court is not the judge of authorizing officers, it is nevertheless required, under article 5, to "report to Parliament on the regularity of the State's financial transactions," a report that "must be published." This article grants it an express mandate. The Constitution supports this view, entrusting the Court with the administrative and jurisdictional control of State revenues and expenditures (art. 200) and obliging it to report annually to the Legislative Body (art. 204).<\/p>

A former minister who has requested a report on their management expects something other than a clearance. They wish to know the conclusions of the examination of their file regarding the regularity of the expenditures for which they were responsible.<\/p>

In my view, the Court should establish this report and submit it to the concerned party. It should also forward it to Parliament, in accordance with its control mission. The problem is that Parliament is currently not in session.<\/p>

A gap that needs to be filled<\/p>

Some will tell me that the procedure does not exist, and they are correct: no text specifies the timeframe within which the Court must submit an individual report to a former minister, nor the form of its transmission, nor the body that receives it in the absence of Parliament. However, this does not prevent the Court from acting.<\/p>

Should we conclude that nothing can be done? I do not believe so.<\/p>

The Court does not need to wait for Parliament's return to carry out its control mission and establish the resulting reports. It can examine files, produce corresponding reports, submit them to the interested parties, and keep a copy for the parliamentary commission, which, when the time comes, will wish to review them.<\/p>

On the day Parliament is functioning again, it will find already established reports rather than files to be started from scratch.<\/p>

Why I care<\/p>

Clearance should neither be a political favor nor an indefinite sanction. This is what I defend in my work, Under the Yoke of Clearance — At the Heart of the Labyrinth of a Control System, particularly in chapter 2, dedicated to the distinction between authorizing officers and accountants, as well as in the last part, where I propose reforms that can be undertaken within the existing legal framework.<\/p>

I call for the rights of managers to be respected and for no one to remain indefinitely in uncertainty.<\/p>

Jean Marie Altéma, MBA<\/p>

Former Director General of CONATEL (2016-2017)<\/p>

Author of Under the Yoke of Clearance — At the Heart of the Labyrinth of a Control System<\/p>

www.souslejougdeladecharge.com<\/p>

References<\/p>

Decree of November 23, 2005, regarding the organization and functioning of the CSCCA<\/p>

Constitution of the Republic of Haiti of March 29, 1987<\/p>

-- <\/p>

Jean Marie Altema [altɛːma], MBA<\/p>

Producer | Manager<\/p>

Haiti Tech Connect podcast<\/p>

He/Him | Founder & CEO<\/p>

profIT Development Consulting | AI Music Tech Conference<\/p>