Impunity, the virus that is rotting the country

From legal impunity to social impunity, two mutations of the same virus allow those responsible for the Haitian crisis to escape their responsibilities and regain their place in society.

Impunity, the virus that is rotting the country

La prison civile de Cabaret (archives)

From legal impunity to social impunity, two mutations of the same virus allow those responsible for the Haitian crisis to escape their responsibilities and regain their place in society. Corruption, gangs, kidnappings, money laundering, and political instability then become manifestations of a system that perpetuates itself. This double protection allows the country to recycle the causes of its own crises.<\/i><\/p>

Corruption, insecurity, armed gangs, kidnappings, money laundering, and political instability are generally addressed as a series of problems to which Haiti must provide specific responses. However, this reading misses the mechanism that connects them. What allows a responsible person to embezzle public resources, a sponsor to finance violence, a criminal network to thrive, a company to enrich itself through inflated public contracts, or a former leader to return to the public sphere after a disastrous record? It is the certainty of not having to answer for one’s actions.<\/p>

Impunity is one of the main mechanisms for reproducing the Haitian crisis. Thus, corruption fuels insecurity, dirty money fuels violence, and the weakness of justice fuels instability. Gangs have grown in an environment where economic and political interests have found in violence a means of control, pressure, or protection. Kidnapping is not just the crime of those who abduct. It implies networks, complicity, financial circuits, and, above all, the conviction that legal consequences can be avoided.<\/p>

Impunity also explains why the same actors can traverse the different crises without disappearing from the scene. They leave power, join their families sheltered abroad, wait for collective memory to fade, and then return as "experienced personalities," "mediators," "experts," or "key interlocutors." Some even propose to form a "council of elders" with the former leaders still alive to help pull the country out of the crisis, with those who are largely responsible for the current situation.<\/p>

It is here that the other dimension of the problem appears, social impunity.<\/p>

Judicial impunity protects a responsible person before the law. Social impunity protects them before society. It allows them to maintain their relationships, status, platforms, and respectability even though they have never had to answer for their public management or their role in the degradation of the country. This can be called name laundering or the recycling of offenders.<\/p>

A large part of civil society, the media, and the economic and intellectual circles participates, often willingly, in this recycling. The same former leaders are invited to give lectures, comment on current events, receive awards, or take on responsibilities again, without being reminded of their records or held accountable. In the diaspora too, some are welcomed as respectable figures and reintroduced into community and economic circles. By presenting them as "statesmen," their past is gradually erased.<\/p>

Haiti cannot escape this mechanism solely through judicial reform. While necessary, it will take time. Therefore, a simultaneous battle against social impunity must also be undertaken.<\/p>

The metaphor of Covid-19 can serve as a guide here. During the pandemic, social distancing helped reduce transmission chains. In the fight against impunity, citizens must also establish a form of distancing from leaders whose responsibility for the country's degradation is established. This sometimes requires cleaning house within our own circle of relationships, whether friends, former comrades, professional relationships, and, when necessary, certain close ones. Our tolerance in our daily interactions largely contributes to normalizing and perpetuating name laundering.<\/p>

This can start with simple but firm gestures. After contributing to the impoverishment, violence, and decay of the country, these officials cannot continue to be welcomed and honored as if nothing has happened. Do not receive them at home, do not seek their company, do not shake their hand, or take pictures with them at receptions and ceremonies. This distance should also extend to those who participated in the system without necessarily holding an official position but who profited from it. Friends, advisors, intermediaries, collaborators, businessmen, and other beneficiaries who served as fronts, obtained fraudulent contracts, or used their proximity to power to enrich themselves should also be targeted.<\/p>

This is not about encouraging division in society. It is rather about refusing to make impunity socially comfortable.<\/p>

This transformation of behaviors must accompany an exceptional judicial response. The significant cases of recent years cannot continue to lie dormant in drawers. PetroCaribe, the massacres in the popular neighborhoods, embezzlement, contracts awarded to fictitious companies, and mechanisms of overbilling must be prioritized.<\/p>

This is not about creating a "people's court" subject to the passions of the street. Instead, a temporary special jurisdiction, composed of independent, honest, and protected magistrates, assisted by financial investigators, must be established with a precise mandate to investigate and judge major cases of corruption, economic crimes, and political violence.<\/p>

A truth and accountability commission could work in parallel to document facts, hear victims, establish chains of responsibility, and preserve the memory of this period. However, it should not replace the courts.<\/p>

Most importantly, trials must occur.<\/p>

It is essential to restore the credibility of the judicial system to signify a real break with past practices. Closer to us, any decision made at the end of the mandate of the Presidential Transition Council (CPT) that serves to protect high-ranking state officials from potential prosecutions must be repealed. Power cannot become a shield against justice.<\/p>

This mechanism must be broken on two fronts. Justice must pursue; society must stop laundering.<\/p>

The first break will be judicial. Investigate, judge, condemn when evidence demands it, and recover funds and property obtained at the expense of the state. The second will be social. End the recycling of offenders and their networks, so that the absence of condemnation no longer automatically becomes a form of rehabilitation. Haitian society must now learn to distance itself from those whose time in power, complicity, or enrichments have contributed to leading the country to this point.<\/p>

Legal impunity has allowed the system to take hold. Social impunity allows it to recycle.<\/p>

It is this double protection that must finally be broken.<\/p>