“The pope was welcomed like a rock star.” This comparison regularly appears in reports on the papal pastoral visits to describe the enthusiastic reception he receives. This analogy has always made me uneasy. It’s being brought up again these days to talk about the fervent, moved, warm throngs that, in stadiums, public squares, or along the roads in Peru and Argentina, are adoring Leon XIV.
I am following this papal journey in South America with great interest, which has taken the pope to Uruguay, Argentina, and Peru, his last stop. Father Robert Prévost, the future Pope Leon XIV, was a missionary in Peru for about twenty years. As a simple rural priest and later as the bishop of the Chiclayo diocese, he left an extraordinary memory in the land of the Incas. Therefore, he is received with the forms and boundless affection appropriate for a son of the house, haloed with the title of successor of Peter.
According to journalists, whether Leon XIV in France in September or in Peru today, or Pope Francis in Brazil in 2013 or Congo in 2023, are welcomed like rock stars. So be it! What are the living rock stars? Does rock as a musical style have mega stars in our times? Do fans of Oum Kalsoum, Bob Marley, Michael Jackson, Marc Anthony, Bad Bunny, or Rihanna identify with rock? And even in the time of Elvis Presley, the uncontested and undeniable King, was he a global celebrity? Or should we understand rock here as a generic term encompassing various musical genres? Still, the cult worshipped by certain music stars (but also in cinema or sports) has been inspired by practices of religious devotion. Not the other way around. Let’s not forget that.
Musical stars or world football champions provoke frenzy among their supporters. People tear their jerseys (at a high price). They plaster their photos on bedroom walls (especially teenagers). They are eager for the slightest gossip about their love lives. They ask for autographs that will become talismans. They imitate their tattoos or their haircut. Each one, in their time, is declared the greatest of all time (GOAT). All of this, in my humble opinion, has nothing to do with the joy mixed with respect, fervor, and affection that Catholics around the world show when they see their spiritual leader. In France yesterday, in Peru today, Leon XIV is received like a Pope.
Kisa rock star pèdi nan koze konsa?
For music or football stars, we are on the field of frenzy. We impoverish ourselves with concert or match tickets that we strive to obtain at any cost on FIFA.com or Ticketmaster, in collectible gadgets, in crazy bets... For the Holy Father, we want to see, listen, pray, commune, nourish ourselves with the word of life. We are in the realm of faith. For the love of God, let’s not mix genres.
Drawing immense crowds wherever they go has been customary for popes since John Paul II systematized the travels of the sovereign pontiff outside of Italy in the late 1970s. The media report that in Buenos Aires on Monday, November 9, 2026, Leon XIV presided over the Eucharist before two and a half million people who gathered in an impressive silence at the moment of consecration. Upon his arrival in Peru on Wednesday, November 11, about three million people had gathered along his route to cheer him. Here are the pontifical standards.
Let’s compare what can be compared. To Caesar what is Caesar’s...
