Rethinking Parliament in the Context of State Fragility

(Towards a model of legislative governance based on competence, accountability, and foresight)A country is not rebuilt solely by a government that decides.

Rethinking Parliament in the Context of State Fragility

Salle de Parlement vide (2019)

(Towards a model of legislative governance based on competence, accountability, and foresight)<\/i><\/p>

A country is not rebuilt solely by a government that decides. It is also rebuilt with a Parliament that understands, legislates, monitors, evaluates, and prepares for the future. There are institutions whose absence eventually becomes a national habit. One adapts to their silence, circumvents their functions, and gradually organizes public life around their non-existence. Then, one day, we realize the cost of this normalization: decisions are made without true parliamentary deliberation, public policies escape regular control by the representatives of the nation, and citizens no longer know precisely which institution to hold accountable. Haiti is facing this trial.<\/p>

After several years of paralysis of the legislative power, the country faces a historic responsibility: to restore a Parliament, certainly, but more importantly to determine what type of Parliament could genuinely contribute to getting the State out of its fragility. This question is fundamental. Because organizing elections is not enough to rebuild an institution. One can renew faces without renewing practices, restore mandates without restoring accountability, fill seats without restoring the capacity for deliberation. The real challenge is thus not only to know who will be elected. It is to determine what skills, what values, what working methods, and what institutional vision should characterize the next Parliament. Haiti does not only need parliamentarians. Haiti needs a Parliament capable of thinking the State, defending the Republic, and preparing for the future.<\/p>

A. THE DIAGNOSIS: AN ABSENT PARLIAMENT, A FRAGILE INSTITUTIONAL BALANCE<\/strong><\/p>

The Haitian Constitution of March 29, 1987 organizes legislative power around two representative chambers: the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate. Together, they constitute the Legislative Body. This architecture is based on an essential principle: popular sovereignty is expressed not only through the election of a head of state or the formation of a government. It also operates through national representation, public deliberation, law-making, and the control of public authorities’ actions. The Parliament thus fulfills several fundamental constitutional functions:<\/p>

1-Representing citizens and communities;<\/i><\/p>

2-Voting laws;<\/i><\/p>

3-Examining and adopting budget texts in accordance with constitutional procedures;<\/i><\/p>

4-Monitoring government action;<\/i><\/p>

5-Participating in balancing powers;<\/i><\/p>

6-Offering an institutional space for democratic confrontation of ideas and interests.<\/i><\/p>

Article 111 of the Constitution entrusts the legislative power with the responsibility to make laws on matters of public interest. This mission should not be reduced to a mere voting formality. The legislative act requires a deep understanding of the problem, an insight into its causes, an evaluation of its consequences, and an appreciation of its effects on the population. The prolonged absence of a functional Parliament therefore has implications that go far beyond the vacancy of seats. It weakens the ordinary mechanisms of control, representation, and deliberation. The prolonged resort to transition governments and decisions made by decree makes the restoration of legitimate, functional, and accountable institutions all the more necessary. The work of the Inter-Parliamentary Union, International IDEA, and organizations specializing in democratic governance reminds us, each in their own way, that Parliament constitutes an essential pillar of public accountability. In the Haitian context, this accountability must be thought of in light of a security, economic, social, and institutional crisis that cannot be resolved by a single institution. Thus, the reconstruction of legislative power must be seen as a strategic component of the reconstruction of the State.<\/p>

B. THE INSTITUTIONAL PROFILE: A PARLIAMENT THAT REPRESENTS, LEGISLATES, AND MONITORS<\/strong><\/p>

The first expected profile of Parliament is that of an institution that fully assumes its constitutional functions. A deputy should not only be the spokesperson for the immediate expectations of his constituency. He must also understand national policies, budgetary mechanisms, the relationships between public authorities, and the territorial consequences of legislative decisions. Likewise, a senator cannot be limited to a political representation of his department. His role should contribute to a national vision, to territorial coherence, and to the continuity of the State. This distinction does not at all mean that parliamentarians should abandon their territories. Rather, it implies that they learn to articulate local needs with the demands of the general interest. Thus, Parliament must exercise three major responsibilities.<\/p>

1. Legislative Responsibility<\/strong><\/p>

A law should never be adopted solely because it responds to a media urgency or an electoral promise. It must provide a legally coherent response to a clearly identified public problem. Before legislating, Parliament should systematically ask itself:<\/p>

  • What public problem does this law seek to solve?<\/li>
  • What data supports the existence of this problem?<\/li>
  • What institutions will be responsible for its implementation?<\/li>
  • What financial and human resources will be necessary?<\/li>
  • What legal, social, and economic risks could it generate?<\/li>
  • By what means will its implementation be evaluated?<\/li><\/ul>

    2. Budgetary Responsibility<\/strong><\/p>

    The State budget constitutes the financial expression of national priorities. It cannot be treated as a mere accounting document. A competent Parliament must be able to understand revenues, expenditures, transfers, public investments, financial commitments, and risks related to debt. It must particularly examine whether public resources correspond to stated objectives, whether expenditures are justified, and whether investments meet the real needs of the population.<\/p>

    3. Control Responsibility<\/strong><\/p>

    Parliamentary control should not be confused with systemic hostility towards the government. Controlling means seeking explanations, examining results, verifying the use of public resources, and identifying discrepancies between commitments and achievements. A Parliament that does not monitor becomes a space for political validation. A Parliament that controls without method risks becoming a theater of confrontation. In contrast, a Parliament that monitors rigorously becomes a true instrument of democratic accountability.<\/p>

    C. THE INTELLECTUAL PROFILE: PARLIAMENTARIANS CAPABLE OF UNDERSTANDING COMPLEXITY<\/strong><\/p>

    In a fragile State, the insufficiency of institutional and analytical capacities can have a particularly high cost. The problems facing Haiti are not isolated. Insecurity affects the economy, population displacements, education, health, territorial administration, and the State's ability to provide public services. A governance crisis can thus turn into a humanitarian crisis and then into a crisis of legitimacy. The next Parliament must therefore go beyond an exclusively political conception of the parliamentary function. It needs to develop a true interdisciplinary intellectual culture. The parliamentarian of tomorrow should possess or be able to mobilize, through specialized support services, fundamental knowledge in several areas:<\/p>

    • Constitutional law and administrative law;<\/li>
    • Public finance and economics;<\/li>
    • Social and territorial policies;<\/li>
    • International relations and diplomacy;<\/li>
    • Human security and conflict prevention;<\/li>
    • Public statistics and data analysis;<\/li>
    • Digital technologies and artificial intelligence;<\/li>
    • Strategic foresight and public policy evaluation.<\/li><\/ul>

      It is not a matter of requiring that every elected official be a lawyer, economist, engineer, or statistician. Such a requirement would be unrealistic. Instead, it is about building an institution in which each elected official knows how to ask the right questions, understand the responses from experts, confront arguments, and make informed decisions. Parliamentary competence is therefore not reduced to holding a degree. It resides in the ability to understand a collective problem, to seek reliable information, to confront viewpoints, and to decide in the general interest.<\/p>

      D. THE METHODOLOGICAL PROFILE: BUILDING EVIDENCE AND EVALUATING PARLIAMENTARY HABITS<\/strong><\/p>

      A modern Parliament cannot operate solely based on impressions, political speeches, or reports transmitted by the administration. It must develop a true working method. To this end, I propose the establishment of a parliamentary cycle of analysis and public decision-making, applicable to major legislative initiatives as well as public policies submitted to chamber scrutiny. This cycle could include seven steps:<\/p>

      1. Identify<\/p>

      Precisely define the public problem and the populations concerned.<\/p>

      2. Document<\/p>

      Gather available data, applicable texts, scientific studies, administrative reports, and testimonies from stakeholders.<\/p>

      3. Analyze<\/p>

      Identify the causes of the problem, its territorial dimensions, its consequences, and its interactions with other sectors of national life.<\/p>

      4. Consult<\/p>

      Organize hearings, public consultations, and exchanges with local authorities, universities, professional organizations, and civil society.<\/p>

      5. Deliberate<\/p>

      Confront different options, examine costs, benefits, risks, and legal consequences.<\/p>

      6. Decide<\/p>

      Adopt a law, formulate a recommendation, or exercise a control function based on explicit and documented arguments.<\/p>

      7. Evaluate<\/p>

      Measure the effects of the decision after its adoption and propose, when necessary, adjustments. This method would help reduce the distance between legislative production and social reality. It would also promote a culture of evidence, in which a political claim can be confronted with facts, a legislative proposal analyzed for its consequences, and a government policy evaluated against verifiable results.<\/p>

      E. THE ETHICAL PROFILE: INDEPENDENCE, TRANSPARENCY, AND ACCOUNTABILITY<\/strong><\/p>

      Competence alone is not enough. An institution may have lawyers, economists, and experts without producing quality governance if its members are not held to high ethical standards. In a country where public trust has been deeply fragile, the next Parliament must be exemplary in its relationship to public money, private interests, and citizens.<\/p>

      It should, in particular, adopt or strengthen:<\/p>

      • A parliamentary code of ethics;<\/li>
      • A system for declaring and preventing conflicts of interest;<\/li>
      • Transparent rules regarding gifts, benefits, and influential relationships;<\/li>
      • The regular publication of attendance and votes;<\/li>
      • The traceability of expenses and parliamentary missions;<\/li>
      • Mechanisms for reporting and addressing breaches;<\/li>
      • Procedures for consultation and accountability to citizens.<\/li><\/ul>

        Parliamentary immunity, within the limits defined by law, must never become a moral license for impunity. An electoral mandate is not private property. It is a temporary responsibility entrusted by the nation. The parliamentarian must understand that he is not the owner of his constituency. He is its representative. This representation involves a permanent obligation to listen, justify, and be accountable.<\/p>

        F. THE TERRITORIAL AND SOCIAL PROFILE: A PARLIAMENT THAT KNOWS THE REAL COUNTRY<\/strong><\/p>

        Haiti cannot be rebuilt solely from Port-au-Prince. The Parliament must reflect the geographic, economic, cultural, and social diversity of the country. It must allow departments, municipalities, communal sections, and populations distant from decision-making centers to have their realities heard. This requirement implies strengthening the ties between parliamentarians and local authorities. A deputy must be able to document the difficulties of his constituency, monitor the state of public infrastructures, identify needs in education, health, drinking water, and energy access, and then bring these concerns into the national debate. A senator must contribute to a broader understanding of departmental priorities and their articulation with national policy. Representation must also be inclusive. Women, youth, persons with disabilities, farmers, workers, entrepreneurs, professionals, academics, and members of the diaspora should find real avenues for participation in parliamentary life. Inclusion must not be a mere decoration in speeches. It must translate concretely into candidacies, consultations, committees, hearings, and public policies. A Parliament that does not know the reality of its territories risks legislating on a country it cannot see.<\/p>

        G. THE PROSPECTIVE PROFILE: A PARLIAMENT THAT DOES NOT ONLY GOVERN THE PRESENT<\/strong><\/p>

        A fragile State is often forced to devote most of its resources to managing emergencies. Yet, the perpetual emergency must never become a doctrine of governance. The Haitian Parliament must learn to look beyond the political calendar and electoral deadlines. It must develop a prospective capacity, that is, the ability to identify possible transformations, anticipate risks, compare scenarios, and prepare decisions that engage future generations. This function could be organized around a parliamentary commission for strategic foresight, evaluation, and public innovation. Its mission would include:<\/p>

        1. Studying demographic, economic, climatic, and technological trends;<\/li>
        2. Assessing risks that could threaten the continuity of the State;<\/li>
        3. Examining the long-term consequences of major reforms;<\/li>
        4. Producing prospective reports on departments and strategic sectors;<\/li>
        5. Monitoring Haiti's national and international commitments;<\/li>
        6. Organizing scientific consultations on the major challenges facing the country.<\/li><\/ol>

          This commission would neither replace the government nor public administrations. It would provide Parliament with analytical and anticipatory tools to better exercise its responsibilities. The question is not to predict the future. It is to make the State less vulnerable to events it could have anticipated.<\/p>

          H. THE PARLIAMENT OF COGNITIVE SOVEREIGNTY: PRODUCING ITS OWN STRATEGIC INTELLIGENCE<\/strong><\/p>

          The reconstruction of Parliament must also be seen as a reconstruction of the State's capacity to produce its own knowledge. A Parliament that exclusively depends on information provided by the Executive cannot fully exercise its control function. A Parliament without autonomous research services risks legislating without having the means necessary to verify the claims presented to it. It thus becomes essential to equip both chambers with a permanent knowledge infrastructure. I propose the creation of a parliamentary research, analysis, and foresight institute, endowed with professional and scientific autonomy and placed at the service of parliamentarians and commissions. This institute could include several units:<\/p>

          • A unit for legal and constitutional research;<\/li>
          • A unit for economic and budgetary analysis;<\/li>
          • A unit for public statistics and data;<\/li>
          • A unit for public policy evaluation;<\/li>
          • A unit for territorial and strategic foresight;<\/li>
          • A unit for parliamentary diplomacy and international cooperation;<\/li>
          • A unit for technological, digital, and algorithmic monitoring.<\/li><\/ul>

            The objective would be to allow elected representatives to have access to independent, verifiable, and contextualized information. This proposal is part of a broader reflection on the cognitive sovereignty of fragile States: the ability of a State to produce, preserve, interpret, contextualize, verify, and mobilize the knowledge necessary to understand its reality and to autonomously formulate its public decisions. In this perspective, the Parliament would no longer be just a place where knowledge produced elsewhere is presented and discussed. It would also become an actor in the production of national public intelligence. Cognitive sovereignty is not intellectual autarky. It does not mean rejecting foreign expertise. It means the ability to cooperate without renouncing understanding, verifying, and deciding for oneself.<\/p>

            I. AN EVALUATION FRAMEWORK TO MEASURE THE QUALITY OF PARLIAMENT<\/strong><\/p>

            To prevent the ideal profile of Parliament from remaining a mere declaration of intent, it is appropriate to propose an evaluation framework. This framework could be organized around ten complementary dimensions:<\/p>

            Dimension<\/th>Evaluation Question<\/th>Possible Indicator<\/th><\/tr><\/thead>
            Representativeness<\/td>Does Parliament reflect the diversity of the country?<\/td>Social, territorial composition, and gender distribution<\/td><\/tr>
            Legislative Competence<\/td>Are the laws based on sufficient analyses?<\/td>Impact studies and consultations conducted<\/td><\/tr>
            Budget Quality<\/td>Are public resources examined rigorously?<\/td>Budget analyses and execution monitoring<\/td><\/tr>
            Democratic Control<\/td>Does the government account for its actions?<\/td>Hearings, reports, and recommendations<\/td><\/tr>
            Integrity<\/td>Do elected representatives respect their ethical obligations?<\/td>Declarations, management of conflicts of interest, and sanctions<\/td><\/tr>
            Transparency<\/td>Can citizens follow the work?<\/td>Publication of votes, expenditures, and minutes<\/td><\/tr>
            Scientific Capacity<\/td>Does Parliament have independent expertise?<\/td>Studies, research services, and university partnerships<\/td><\/tr>
            Territorial Anchoring<\/td>Are the realities of communities integrated?<\/td>Consultations and territorial reports<\/td><\/tr>
            Inclusion<\/td>Do underrepresented groups actually participate?<\/td>Participation in committees and hearings<\/td><\/tr>
            Foresight<\/td>Does Parliament prepare long-term decisions?<\/td>Prospective studies and risk monitoring<\/td><\/tr><\/tbody><\/table><\/figure>

            This framework should not be used as a premature political ranking tool. It would primarily serve as a tool for institutional diagnosis, monitoring, and continuous improvement. Its relevance should be tested, documented, and gradually adapted to national realities.<\/p>

            In summary, the next legislature will not be an ordinary legislature. It will inherit a country faced with a security crisis, deep institutional fragility, social emergencies, and a lasting loss of trust in representation mechanisms. It must therefore do more than resume interrupted parliamentary activities. It will need to contribute to restoring the legitimacy of the State, to reconstructing the balance of powers, and to improving the quality of public decision-making to make it more rational, more transparent, and closer to citizens. A Parliament worthy of this mission must possess five essential qualities: the competence to understand, the independence to control, the integrity to serve, the method to decide, and the vision to anticipate. It must be capable of voting laws without yielding to haste, controlling the Executive without turning oversight into vendetta, defending territorial interests without sacrificing the general interest, and cooperating with international partners without abandoning national judgment capacity. Tomorrow’s Parliament should not merely mirror the power dynamics of Haitian society. It must become one of the instruments of its transformation. For the Republic is not rebuilt solely by the strength of its governments. It is also rebuilt by the quality of its representatives, the solidity of its institutions, and the capacity of its citizens to hold them accountable. Haiti deserves a Parliament that does not merely occupy the present but works to make the future possible.<\/p>

            Me Jonel Dilhomme, Av.
            <\/strong>Researcher in international law and global governance
            Analyst of foresight applied to fragile States and Haiti's future
            Researcher on the general theory of cognitive sovereignty applied to fragile States
            Former professor at the State University of Haiti
            Email: Jonel.dilhomme30@gmail.com<\/p>

            SELECTIVE REFERENCES<\/p>

            • Republic of Haiti, Constitution of March 29, 1987<\/i>, notably the provisions regarding legislative power, articles 88 and following, and legislative functions, from article 111.<\/li>
            • Inter-Parliamentary Union, Parline: Data on the Haitian Parliament<\/i>.<\/li>
            • OECD, OECD Reviews of Public Governance: Haiti<\/i>, 2021.<\/li>
            • United Nations, BINUH, Report of the Secretary-General on the Integrated Office of the United Nations in Haiti<\/i>, S/2026/31, January 15, 2026.<\/li>
            • Human Rights Watch, World Report 2026: Haiti<\/i>.<\/li>
            • Provisional Electoral Council, Updated electoral calendar 2026-2027<\/i>, publication of October 28, 2026.<\/li>
            • Provisional Electoral Council, press releases of November 9 and 10, 2026 concerning the registration of political structures and candidacies.<\/li><\/ul>