Public Governance Tensions

Conflicts over Attributions: Case of the MPCE (4/5)

In the previous article, we examined the mechanisms that create tensions within public bodies, particularly within a ministry and the Prime Minister's office.

Conflicts over Attributions: Case of the MPCE (4/5)

Salle de réunion vide

In the previous article, we examined the mechanisms that create tensions within public bodies, particularly within a ministry and the Prime Minister's office. We described strategies used by political cabinets or authorities to overshadow managers: duplication of management structures, control of scarce resources, marginalization of managers, distrust, and sidelining of technical expertise.

In this article, we examine tensions related to attributions and competencies. We rely on illustrations from the Ministry of Planning and External Cooperation (MPCE). These cases have led to public controversies. They will allow us to assess the ability of actors to protect the institution's image even in times of public governance tensions and to adhere to the fundamental principles of public service.

Tensions over Attributions: Case of the MPCE

The cases of tension illustrated in this section have been covered in the press. Indeed, they have transcended the organizational framework due to a lack of effective arbitration from political power.

Presentation of Facts

During April 2019, nomination letters were distributed at the ministry on the instruction of Minister Jean Claudy Pierre. The General Director of the ministry, Stevenson Jacques Timoléon, adopted a circular to qualify the minister's act as an 'infringement of the established administrative procedure at the MPCE' in the event of confirmation (Revange, 2019, April 16).

Furthermore, on July 17 and 18, 2019, the minister adopted two (2) circulars aimed at central directors, departmental directors, and other relevant actors within the ministry to inform them of the adoption of new seals, thereby canceling the old ones (Revange, 2019, July 20). The General Director of the ministry deemed the minister's action unilateral and illegal. Prior to these episodes in July, the minister instructed his General Director to return the ministry seals on June 5, 2020, but rather took care to inform the ministry's services that the seals had been kept and were available in his office (Revange, 2019, July 20).

On July 19, 2019, he addressed the resigning minister in these rather ungracious terms (Revange, 2019, July 20):

“Consequently, the General Directorate hastens to inform you that the highest authorities of the State have been notified of such deviations and until further notice, the existing stamps remain the same as before.”

Reminder of Ministerial and General Director Attributions

The minister is the highest administrative authority of the ministry and holds powers of appointment, management, instruction, and reform (article 40 of the Decree of May 17, 2005 on State central administration, DACE). Indeed, his appointment power is exercised in that he can appoint, by delegation from the Prime Minister, to certain public jobs in accordance with the applicable standards (article 40.1 of the DACE). His management power concerns the ministry's activities and the State's resources dedicated to the ministry (article 40.3 of the DACE). His instruction power resides in his ability to give instructions and directives to the heads of the various entities of the ministry, including the General Directorate (article 40.4 of the DACE).

It is important to remind some of the attributions of the General Director of the ministry to better analyze this media-framed situation of tension. Being the head of the ministry's main management structure, namely the General Directorate, he ensures the organization, direction, coordination, control, and supervision of the ministry's activities, under the minister's supervision; and participates in the design of sectoral policy and its implementation, as well as in executing the minister's instructions (articles 58 and 60 of the DACE).

Case of Appointments Outside the Administrative Circuit

Regarding nomination letters prepared, signed, and distributed to individuals without going through the regular administrative circuit, it is essential to recall that the process should be managed by the General Directorate of the ministry, through the Human Resources Directorate (DRH), the Administrative Affairs and Budget Directorate (DAAB), and the designated assignment service. The DRH ensures that candidates with the best professional assets are recruited to perform the desired mandate through a process guaranteeing competitiveness, equality, and integrity. In collaboration with the General Directorate of the ministry and the Office of Management and Human Resources (OMRH), in some cases, it contributes to establishing career plans, staff planning, the implementation of development and motivation programs, and compliance with the provisions of the General Status of the Public Service (Article 72 of the DACE amended in 2016). The DAAB ensures that the appointment adheres to budgetary constraints. Lastly, recruitment should meet the needs of the service. The entire recruitment process should respect meritocratic rules.

If the DRH is an essential actor in the recruitment process, it should also collaborate with the General Directorate of the ministry in managing human resources. Moreover, each director is required to report their activities to the General Director of the ministry and to follow up on all instructions or directives from the General Directorate (articles 58 and 69 of the DACE). Therefore, the circulation of a significant number of nomination letters without the involvement of the General Director of the ministry, outside the meritocratic rules of the General Status of the Public Service and without concern for efficiency, infringes upon the established administrative process.

However, even though the heads of departments must report to the General Director of the ministry and execute his instructions, it is the instructions of the minister that will take precedence in cases of confusion between directives, as he is the highest administrative authority of the ministry (article 40 of the DACE). Additionally, the minister has the power of reform (article 40.5 of the DACE):

“The Minister's power of reform is to cancel or reform decisions of the heads of the various structures of the Ministry that do not comply with the laws and his instructions and directives. However, this power of reform cannot be exercised against acts that were carried out in accordance with a law that expressly attributes to them specific competencies.”

In cases where the minister's instructions contradict legal provisions, the DRH and DAAB could decide not to follow them. They clearly have the competencies to ensure the conformity of the recruitment process to the General Status of the Public Service. In management, the hierarchical chain must be clearly established and respect Fayol's principle of unity of command, according to which each agent receives instructions from a single hierarchical authority and only reports to it. When service heads receive orders from both the minister, the Cabinet Director, and the General Director of the ministry, it is likely to create confusion regarding instructions and priorities.

Confiscation of Seals by the General Director

Going back to the confiscation of seals, the minister has the power to manage the State resources made available to the ministry (article 40.3 of the DACE). Seals are part of these resources. Consequently, the General Director must follow the instructions of the minister. However, the minister should ensure that he acts in accordance with good management practices, administrative procedures, and laws. He must also show deference to his General Director by informing him of the actions to be taken. It is the General Directorate that ensures the implementation of the minister's instructions and also compliance with the organic laws of the ministry (see article 60 of the DACE). Under no circumstances should the minister directly manage the day-to-day operations of the ministry without undermining his capacity to prioritize the strategic dimensions of his attributions or weaken the authority of the General Director. The consequences can be multiple: confusion over attributions, decreased motivation, deterioration of the work climate, and a dynamics of allegiance of agents towards their preferred chief.

Overall, the attributions of the main actors of a ministry are likely to present a certain permeability instead of perfect impermeability. They are associated and interwoven. It is the degree of permeability that makes all the difference, given that they are called to work in harmony. The best thing is to always define processes that are clear enough for all. It is also advisable to utilize communication mechanisms when tension arises. Communication proves to be a good tool in reducing tensions. Without communication or arbitration, dirty laundry tends to be washed in public, thus hurting the reputation of the public institution. An uncredible public institution will reinforce citizens' negative perceptions of the State. Once public trust is lost, it is difficult to regain it. This trust is necessary for citizen participation and public service delivery that meets citizens' expectations.

As actors in a public body, officials must ensure compliance with the rules, procedures, policies, and laws governing the operation of the ministry. They must also ensure that their actions are in accordance with the normative framework of public administration.

In the next and final article, we will examine the issues of tensions for decision-making processes, especially the aspects of legitimacy and credibility of the decision. We will use a study from the UPAC developed by Garzón and Bautista-Beauchesne (2021). We will also emphasize the role of political authority as an arbitrator in restoring order and harmony within the organization, as well as balancing divergent interests. We will also revisit some recommendations from previous articles.